18 Nov 2026
By Stephen Forsyth, Partner, Litigation, Gilson Gray
When Does a Football Insult Become a Legal Wrong?
Football thrives on opinion. It also thrives on rivalry, criticism and, increasingly, provocative commentary designed to generate debate.
But where is the legal line between a robust, even offensive, opinion and something that gives rise to a claim?
That question has unexpectedly arisen after Aston Villa announced an intention to raise a legal action against Jamie Carragher. The club said that it would initiate proceedings over what chairman Nassef Sawiris described as “unacceptable insults about the club and its fans”.
The controversy arose from comments Carragher made on the Stick to Football podcast while discussing the possibility of Villa manager Unai Emery taking the Manchester United job. Carragher argued that there remains a hierarchy between football clubs, said that Aston Villa would “never be [as big as] Manchester United” and used distinctly robust language when addressing Villa supporters.
The club’s response has attracted considerable attention. The threat of legal action has since been recalled. Legally, however, the more interesting question is: what exactly could a football club sue for if a similar thing happened north of the border?
The Scottish legal position
In Scotland, defamation is governed principally by the Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021.
Under section 1, it is not enough that a statement is insulting or offensive. A defamation action only arises where the statement has been published to someone other than the person complained about and has caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to that person’s reputation.
There is an additional hurdle for commercial organisations. Where the pursuer is a non-natural person whose primary purpose is trading for profit, reputational harm does not amount to “serious harm” unless it has caused, or is likely to cause, serious financial loss.
That distinction could be significant in a dispute of this kind. Being publicly insulted is one thing. Establishing the serious harm required by the legislation is another.
Insult or opinion?
There is also a fundamental distinction between making a defamatory factual allegation and expressing an opinion.
Section 7 of the 2021 Act provides a statutory defence of honest opinion. Among other requirements, the statement must be an opinion rather than a statement of fact; it must indicate the evidence upon which the opinion is based, and an honest person must have been capable of holding that opinion on the basis of that evidence.
Carragher’s reported argument that Aston Villa will “never be Manchester United”, and his views about the relative hierarchy of football clubs, would therefore raise an obvious question about whether those remarks are properly characterised as statements of fact at all.
Football supporters may strongly disagree with such opinions. The law does not, however, provide a remedy simply because an opinion is provocative, insulting or unpopular.
The wider lesson is therefore an important one for businesses as well as football clubs.
An insult is not necessarily a defamation.
Before threatening proceedings, consideration should be given to exactly what the words mean, whether they assert fact or opinion, who they identify, how widely they have been published and, crucially, whether the statutory threshold of serious harm can actually be established.
The Aston Villa-Carragher dispute may have begun with football banter, but it provides a useful reminder that the boundary between offensive speech and actionable reputational damage is an important legal one.
If, however, persistent (more than two) public comments are made which go beyond conduct that is irritating, annoying, unattractive or unreasonable, a person may have grounds for seeking a Non-Harassment Order. For further guidance, read our article on Non-Harassment Orders: Understanding Your Rights and Legal Options.
Gilson Gray’s award-winning Litigation Team advises individuals and businesses on disputes involving reputation, commercial interests and contentious communications. Early advice can be particularly important where material has been published online or through social media, both in assessing whether legal action is justified and in deciding upon the most effective response.